In Brightest Day, in Blackest Night
SF Masterworks #5: The Stars My Destination, by Alfred Bester
Spoiler Warning: This review gives away the plot of the book. Completely.
He was one hundred and seventy days dying and not yet dead. He fought for survival with the passion of a beast in a trap. He was delirious and rotting, but occasionally his primitive mind emerged from the burning nightmare of survival into something resembling sanity. Then he lifted his mute face to Eternity and muttered: “What’s a matter, me? Help, you goddamn gods! Help, is all.”
— opening lines of Chapter 1 of The Stars My Destination, by Alfred Bester
In 1943, a young scriptwriter at DC Comics gave the Green Lantern his oath. "In brightest day, in blackest night / No evil shall escape my sight." The lines have survived eight decades, several reboots and at least one terrible film (and, since I originally wrote this article, a halfway decent TV series with a weak ending). They read like some Victorian incantation. That's because their author understood that a superhero's mantra must work as ritual. He had learned this from Bill Finger, the star comics writer of the period, who on a rainy Saturday afternoon gave a potential rival what Bester later called "an incisive, illuminating lecture on the craft." Bester regarded that afternoon as a high point in the generosity of one colleague to another.
Thirteen years after this lesson in narrative, the man who wrote the Green Lantern's catchphrase published one of the most formally ambitious science fiction novels of the 1950s.
In the twenty-fifth century, humanity has learned to "jaunte", to teleport by mental effort alone. Overnight, the transport trade collapses and every house has to be plated against intruders, while the Inner Planets go to war with the Outer Satellites.
At the bottom of this world sits Gully Foyle, an uneducated ship's mechanic going nowhere. After 170 days alone in the wreck of the Nomad, he signals a passing liner, the Vorga, which ignores him and moves on. As we learn much later, the ship's officers had nothing personal against him; they were merely following corporate orders. But that snub is what keeps him alive. He now sets his mind entirely on settling the score.
He is picked up by the Scientific People, a cargo cult living on an asteroid in the Sargasso, who tattoo a Maori-style tiger mask onto his face and marry him to a woman named Moira. He flees in one of the lost spaceships that make up their habitat, destroying much of the Sargasso in the process. Eventually captured on Earth, he finds himself in the subterranean dark of Gouffre Martel, an underground prison kept completely black so the inmates have no visual coordinates for a jaunte. In those caves he falls in with a sharp-witted thief named Jisbella McQueen, who helps him escape. Foyle then abandons Jisbella, recovers a fortune from the Nomad and buys himself a brand-new identity. Back-street doctors speed up his nervous system and scrub the tattoos from his skin. He buys his way into polite society under a comic-book alias, pretending to be the wealthy buffoon Geoffrey Fourmyle of Ceres.
Then he sets out to hunt down the people he holds responsible for the Vorga's order. In the process he discovers that the ship was carrying PyrE, a substance detonated by thought with enough energy to destroy the solar system. The person who actually gave the order to abandon him turns out to be his enemy's daughter, Olivia Presteign, who is blind to ordinary light and sees the world only in infrared. Foyle falls in love with her. She turns out to be a genuine sociopath.
When the PyrE finally goes off, Foyle is buried alive in the flaming wreckage of St Patrick's Cathedral. Half out of his mind in the fire, he hits on the real secret of jaunting, which can carry a man across centuries and light-years just like jumping across a room. Bouncing through his own timeline, he realises that he himself is the spectral "Burning Man" who appeared aboard the Nomad in the opening chapter. We finally understand how Foyle had managed to stay alive in the wreck of the Nomad at the very beginning of the story. Thrown out into empty space, he had jaunted blindly into the ship's hull without realising that such a jump was even possible. Foyle scatters the PyrE among the common people and tells them it is their responsibility to decide whether they are men or animals. Then he returns to the wreckage of the Nomad, now part of the Scientific People's salvage asteroid, and curls up in his old tool locker, burning with revelation. Moira finds him. Joseph, the Scientific People's priest, comes to exact punishment but sees that Foyle has already found it in himself. They settle down alongside him and prepare to await his awakening.
Bester was open about his structural debt to Alexandre Dumas. In his autobiographical essay "My Affair with Science Fiction" (collected in Hell's Cartographers, 1975), he wrote:
For some time I'd been toying with the notion of using the Count of Monte Cristo pattern for a story. The reason is simple; I'd always preferred the anti-hero and I'd always found high drama in compulsive types.
The notion remained inert until Bester found a pile of old National Geographics in his cottage on Fire Island. One contained a piece on the survival of torpedoed sailors. The record was held by a Philippine cook's helper who had lasted roughly four months on an open raft. The detail that "racked him up" was this: the man had been sighted several times by passing ships which refused to change course, because it was a common Nazi submarine trick to put out decoys. "The magpie mind darted down, picked it up," Bester wrote, "and the notion was transformed into a developing story with a strong attack."
Two years earlier, he had tried out the same basic revenge plot in his 1954 story "5,271,009". The story already has the mangled Germanic slang that reappears in Stars, so Bester had obviously been tinkering with broken technical jargon for a while. It also has a string of pneumatic women lined up as potential wives for the hero. Bester never really shook that breezy 1950s habit of treating women as prizes for his male protagonists. Even the title of his autobiographical essay, "My Affair with Science Fiction," carries the implications of a brief but satisfying dalliance.
On the surface, Bester sticks closely to Dumas. Like Edmond Dantes, Foyle is betrayed, locked up, educated in the dark by a fellow prisoner, and finally turned loose with the money to hunt down his enemies. Yet Bester turns the morality of the French novel inside out. Dantes is an innocent young sailor who is ruined by a conspiracy, pulled back into society by the saintly Abbe Faria, and then sent into the world with a treasure map, which he can use to pursue his revenge. Foyle is a brute abandoned out of pure corporate indifference. His own teacher in Gouffre Martel is Jisbella the thief, and she only schools him in etiquette so he can get within striking distance of his targets. When he finally recovers the Nomad's prize, it turns out to be a stash of PyrE that could crack planets open.
As D. Harlan Wilson points out in the Palgrave companion to the novel, Dantes invents the Count to play God, whereas Foyle invents Fourmyle of Ceres to play a confidence trick. Even then, his disguise barely holds together whenever his temper gets the better of him. When, finally, both heroes pull back from their vengeance and walk away from society, they do it on entirely different terms. Dumas' Count chooses mercy when he sees that his plot has started to kill innocent bystanders. Foyle has no interest in that kind of mercy, and instead gives the PyrE away to the public, leaving ordinary men and women to decide their own fate.
The novel opens with an epigram from William Blake's "The Tyger," and the poem's shadow falls across every page. The original UK title was Tiger! Tiger!, taken directly from Blake. In the burst of exposition that makes up the prologue, Bester attributes the ability to jaunte to the "tigroid" substance in human nerve cells, a real term for the Nissl bodies found in neurons. The Scientific People ink tiger stripes onto Foyle's face, permanently marking him as an apex predator. The opening quotation, "Tyger Tyger, burning bright," also points straight to the end of the book, where Foyle stumbles through the burning ruins of the cathedral and transcends into a new form of being. Foyle, like Blake's tiger, is a terrifying creature whose fire and origins are a mystery to the world around it.
The prologue itself, with its rolling antitheses ("It was a golden age, a time of high adventure, rich living, and hard dying..."), is a recognisable riff on the opening of A Tale of Two Cities. Bester uses it to show us a society in which teleportation has set people free while making every bedroom in the solar system vulnerable to trespassers.
The deeper literary debt is to James Joyce. In "My Affair with Science Fiction," Bester discusses his obsession with Joyce at length. The most obvious sign of it is the wild typesetting during Foyle's synaesthesia sequence, where words zig-zag across the page in different fonts to imitate his scrambled senses. Without printing actual illustrations, a novelist in 1956 could hardly have come closer to the look of a comic book. Delany, in The Jewel-Hinged Jaw, argued that this sequence was also a dramatisation of Rimbaud's theory of the "systematic derangement of the senses to achieve the unknown," and that the Rimbaud reference was as conscious as the references to Joyce and Blake. But the subtler and more interesting parallel, identified by Wilson, is structural. The nursery rhyme that frames the novel, "Gully Foyle is my name / And Terra is my nation. / Deep space is my dwelling place, / The stars my destination," revises a lyric from A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man: "Stephen Dedalus is my name, / Ireland is my nation. / Clongowes is my dwellingplace / and heaven my expectation." Dedalus' childhood doodling is transposed to a chant that Foyle mutters in the dark to keep himself alive.
Bester got into comics because several of his pulp editors moved to DC and brought him along. During his time there he wrote for Superman, Batman and Green Lantern before growing bored with their narrative constraints and moving into radio. But he took the medium's visual habits with him, and reused them in his prose.
The cut scenes near the end of Stars read like storyboard directions. At one point, an accomplice of Foyle's falls to his death, and Bester cuts Jisbella's reaction together like three or four panels in a comic strip. There are no linking sentences; one sharp image simply slams into the next. The jumps at the climax of the book use the same trick (what would in comic books be "gutter jumps"), leaving blanks on the page so the reader's imagination has to supply the missing motion between panels.
The scattered typesetting is Bester's most obvious comic-book trick. Foyle's tiger tattoo is a quieter one. The ink on Foyle's face conveys his mood through a kind of superhero mask. Calm, he looks like any other rich gentleman who has had good plastic surgery. Angry, he has blood-red stripes burning through his skin. Comic books use thought bubbles and expressive art to demonstrate a character's inner state. The tattoo lets Bester do that in prose.
All of these techniques converge in the synaesthesia sequence at the novel's climax. All that scattered type and staccato cutting builds into a genuine "I give you the stars" climax worthy of Stapledon or Clarke. It is one of the finest endings in the genre. I had to put the book down and walk round the room a few times when I first finished it. The only other novel that has ever done that to me is One Hundred Years of Solitude. These are, of course, very different books. What they have in common is a kind of euphoric aftertaste that follows you for ten minutes or so after you finish them, leaving the ordinary world outside the window feeling much too small.
Robin Wednesbury is, for the period, a remarkable creation. She is black, intelligent, telepathically gifted and central to the plot. Four times in the book she is called a "Negro" - jarring for modern readers but in 1956 standard, polite usage. (Elsewhere, in "My Affair with Science Fiction", Bester actually uses the full racial slur in the middle of an aside meant to sound broad-minded. So much for the depth of 1950s Manhattan liberalism.)
Whatever goodwill he built up evaporates when Foyle rapes her. Aside from being ugly on its own terms, the assault creates a mess in the plotting of the book. Robin is a "telesender": she can broadcast her thoughts telepathically, though she cannot receive them. Bester needs her for the Monte Cristo plot as a kind of Cyrano, following Foyle through polite society and whispering instructions into his head. Unfortunately, this leaves her wide open to anyone standing within earshot of her thoughts. Bester always worked his plots out like clockwork. He leaves Robin with no way to protect herself and then pushes the situation to its worst possible outcome. At no point does he stop to remember that he is writing the book and is under no obligation to do this.
It happens offstage. Foyle corners Robin, threatens to report her as an alien-belligerent to Intelligence, carries her to a couch, and throws her down. "Nothing," he repeats. The scene fades to black. Later, Robin accuses him of rape. Near the end of the novel, Foyle confesses to it. Neil Gaiman, in his introduction to the Byron Preiss edition, treats the scene as an example of 1956 reticence: in modern writing, he suggests, the rape would take place onstage. But explicitness is not the problem. One wants to reply to Mr Gaiman that in better modern writing the only black female character would not be raped at all.
Foyle's commission of the act is not the real problem. For the book to work at all, Foyle has to begin at absolute zero, with nothing inside him except violence and spite. The difficulty is what happens after the act. Robin forgives him. She continues to work with him. Bester clearly thinks her forgiveness shows how noble she is; reading it now, you just wince.
Some of the fault lies with his source material. Film versions and abridged paperbacks usually trim The Count of Monte Cristo down into a harmless swashbuckler. The unredacted original is a much darker book that includes sexual violence and the abduction of Haydee's mother into slavery. But Dumas never expects the reader to accept a rape by the hero as just another stage in his spiritual growth. Bester wants to follow Dumas' structure so closely - it's the engine of the book. But he wanders into territory that his own mid-century liberalism is ill-equipped to handle.
The Palgrave companion to the novel puts this bluntly. Rape is a recurrent theme in Bester's work. It surfaces in "Fondly Fahrenheit," where Vandaleur speculates that his psychotic android may have raped a child. A posthumously published novel, ostensibly a satire of Madison Avenue, was originally titled Tender Loving Rape until his editor Charles Platt persuaded him to change it to Tender Loving Rage. (It is godawful.) Wilson describes Gully as the "most hostile, reprehensible rapist of all." Bester does not condone the act explicitly or implicitly; Foyle's violence is framed as the behaviour of an "Unleashed Id" that must be overcome. Bester leaves Robin to do the forgiving so that Foyle can move forward, and never stops to reckon with the damage done to her. Wilson observes that "scholarship on his work has collectively glossed over the issue."
Like many male science fiction authors of the 1950s, Bester generally struggles with female characters. When Jisbella complains that jaunting has locked women back into the seraglio ("After a thousand years of civilisation we're still property"), it is a rare flash of social criticism, yet Bester still uses her anger mainly as a teaching aid to smarten up his hero. Bester's women are beautiful, dedicated to the hero, and, as Charles Platt noted in Dream Makers, "altogether delightfully ineffectual."
Few science fiction novels have been praised so widely and for such different reasons. M. John Harrison identified the novel's political core: "Bester was one of the first to see that Popular Mechanics does not free but enslave us." Harrison's point sets Bester squarely against John W. Campbell, who liked his science fiction to work like a manual for clever engineers. A bright young man with a slide rule would get eaten alive in the world of Stars.
In The Jewel-Hinged Jaw, Delany paid closer attention to the sentences themselves. He used Bester's book to demonstrate how science fiction takes dead figures of speech and makes them literally true inside the story. William Gibson, writing for the Library of America, remembered rediscovering the novel in his twenties and finding it built on "bones pilfered from Dumas and Dickens (steal only the best)," clad in "archly sophisticated Mad Ave ur-hipness" that made most of its assumed genre "look hick." Bruce Sterling, Gibson reported, called it "a seamless pop artifact." The cyberpunk movement is often presented as the novel's most important legacy, but K.W. Jeter offered a useful corrective: "What's being labeled as cyberpunk is just the usual rediscovery of Alfred Bester that happens every two or three years in the SF field." Almost everything supposedly new, Jeter argued, "really resembles nothing so much as Alfred Bester's closet (or his wastebasket)".
Ty Franck, one half of the James S.A. Corey partnership, has said that The Stars My Destination changed the way he thought about plotting a story. In The Expanse, Franck and Daniel Abraham set up the exact same cold war between the inner planets and the outer belt, and kick the plot off with the runaway daughter of a rich family and a strange new substance that could wreck the solar system. Even James Holden's compulsion to broadcast dangerous secrets to the public comes straight out of Foyle's playbook. Over in Britain, Alan Moore had already tipped his hat to Bester in the 1970s, calling an early strip he drew for the music paper Sounds "The Stars My Degradation". And when, around the same time, ITV produced its telefantasy answer to Doctor Who, The Tomorrow People, its young mutants teleported by "jaunting." Only steal from the best, as Gibson says.
Bester picked up his visual tricks from comics before the post-war moral panic drove the industry into watering down its work. Back when Bester was scripting comic books, adults still read newspaper strips by Will Eisner and Milton Caniff in the millions. By the time Stars came out in 1956, Fredric Wertham, the Senate hearings, and the Comics Code had scared comic-book publishers into printing harmless fare for children. Two decades later, Howard Chaykin and Byron Preiss adapted The Stars My Destination as an early graphic novel (started in 1979 and finally finished in 1992). In doing so, they brought the book back to the medium from which Bester had learned how to cut a scene.
Delany referred to the book as "considered by many readers and writers, both in and outside the field, to be the greatest single SF novel." The quote appears on some current editions. It remains a masterpiece of 1950s science fiction, though time has been hard on parts of it. Its speed and invention are still as striking now as at the time of its original publication. Its uglier blind spots, however, are much harder on the eye. Its evils, which seem to have escaped the sight of the author in 1956, burn perhaps too brightly for the modern reader.
Sources
Alfred Bester, The Stars My Destination (Signet, 1957; originally published as Tiger! Tiger!, Sidgwick & Jackson, 1956). The current Gollancz SF Masterworks edition is the most widely available UK text.
Alfred Bester, "My Affair with Science Fiction," in Brian Aldiss and Harry Harrison (eds), Hell's Cartographers (Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1975).
Alfred Bester, "5,271,009," in Virtual Unrealities: The Short Fiction of Alfred Bester (Vintage, 1997; still in print). Originally published in Fantasy and Science Fiction, March 1954. See also James Wallace Harris, "5,271,009 by Alfred Bester," Auxiliary Memory, 29 June 2018.
Alfred Bester, Tender Loving Rage (Tafford, 1991). Originally written in 1959 as Tender Loving Rape; title changed at the suggestion of Charles Platt.
Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo (1844).
D. Harlan Wilson (ed.), Alfred Bester's The Stars My Destination (Palgrave Science Fiction and Fantasy: A New Canon, 2019). Source for the Joyce/Portrait of the Artist parallel, the discussion of rape in Bester's work, and the Platt and Harrison quotations cited in this essay.
Samuel R. Delany, The Jewel-Hinged Jaw: Notes on the Language of Science Fiction (Dragon Press, 1977; revised edition, Wesleyan University Press, 2009). Source for the Rimbaud/"systematic derangement of the senses" reading and the analysis of how science fiction sentences function.
Charles Platt, Dream Makers: The Uncommon People Who Write Science Fiction (Berkley, 1980). Source for the "altogether delightfully ineffectual" observation on Bester's female characters.
William Gibson, "Alfred Bester," Library of America. Source for "bones pilfered from Dumas and Dickens" and Sterling's "seamless pop artifact."
K.W. Jeter, quoted in Michael Bishop, Preface to "In Memoriam: Alfred Bester 1913-1987," in Michael Bishop (ed.), Nebula Awards 23 (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1987), 22-24. Cited in Wilson.
Neil Gaiman, Introduction to the Byron Preiss edition of The Stars My Destination (iBooks, 1996).
Howard Chaykin and Byron Preiss, The Stars My Destination (graphic adaptation; Volume One, Baronet, 1979; complete edition, Epic/Marvel, 1992).
Jad Smith, Alfred Bester (Modern Masters of Science Fiction, University of Illinois Press, 2017). Discusses the Ouspensky and Ali Nomad connections not explored in this essay.
Member discussion